If your business website displays customer reviews or embeds Google reviews, the FTC’s rule on fake and deceptive reviews, 16 CFR Part 465, applies to you even though you never collected a single review yourself. The rule took effect October 21, 2024 and covers any business that creates, buys, obtains, republishes, or displays consumer reviews, which includes a contractor or HVAC company pulling its own Google reviews onto its site. Violations can trigger civil penalties for knowing conduct, and the practical risk for a small home service business is less about a surprise fine and more about a handful of common display habits that cross the line without anyone noticing.

What counts as a review under this rule

The rule reaches further than a dedicated reviews page. It covers star ratings on your homepage, embedded Google review widgets, testimonial quotes pulled from email, and video testimonials in your service pages. Any of these can trigger a violation if the underlying review is fake, materially altered, or displayed in a way that misrepresents how representative it is of the reviews you actually received. A home service business that simply mirrors its real Google reviews onto its own site is not automatically at risk. The risk shows up in a specific set of practices the rule singles out.

Buying, creating, or incentivizing reviews the wrong way

The rule bans creating or buying reviews from people who never used your service, materially rewriting a customer’s actual experience into something more flattering, and paying for reviews on the condition that they’re positive. A contractor offering a gift card for an honest review, regardless of rating, is on solid ground. The same contractor offering that gift card only if the customer leaves five stars, or asking a customer to change a three-star review to five stars in exchange for a discount, is squarely inside the banned conduct. The distinction is whether the reward depends on the sentiment of the review, not on whether a review gets left at all.

Review gating and the “all our reviews” problem

A common setup for home service websites routes happy customers to a public review link and routes unhappy customers to a private complaint form instead, then displays only the public reviews as if they represented the whole customer base. That selective routing, combined with language implying completeness, is what the rule calls review gating, and it is explicitly prohibited. The following table lays out the difference between a defensible setup and one that crosses the line.

Practice Compliant version Violation
Review request flow Same request sent to every customer regardless of expected rating Only satisfied customers get a public review link
Display claim “Reviews shown below are pulled from our Google profile” “100% verified customer reviews” with no verification process
Negative reviews Removed only for spam, no real customer match, or policy violation Removed because the rating was low

Undisclosed insider reviews

An owner, manager, or employee posting a review of their own company without disclosing the connection is a separate violation, even if every word of the review is true. This comes up more often than owners expect: an employee leaving a glowing review under a personal account, or an owner’s spouse posting a testimonial that reads like an ordinary customer’s. The fix is simple disclosure, a line noting the reviewer’s connection to the business, not avoiding internal reviews altogether.

Review hijacking across services or locations

If your business operates under one brand across several service lines or locations, repurposing a review written about one job as if it applies to a different service or branch is banned as review hijacking. A plumbing company reusing a water heater installation review as a testimonial for a new HVAC division, without the reviewer ever having used that service, falls into this category even when the original review is entirely genuine.

What a defensible Google review display actually looks like

Embedding real Google reviews on your site, as described in Embedding Google Reviews on Your Website, is not itself a problem under the rule. The questions that matter are whether the feed is unedited, whether you’re filtering by rating before display, and whether any caption or headline overstates how thoroughly the reviews were checked. A plain statement such as “Reviews below are pulled directly from our Google Business Profile” carries less risk than a banner claiming “100% verified real customer reviews” next to reviews you never checked against a job record. If you collect your own written testimonials with a customer’s name and photo instead, that raises a separate disclosure and consent question covered in Customer Testimonials: What the Law Requires.

Common mistakes worth fixing this week

The most frequent issue is a review widget inherited from a web template that quietly filters by star rating, something many owners never configured themselves and don’t realize is running. A second issue is a staff incentive program, built with good intentions, that ties a reward to a specific rating instead of just asking for feedback. A third is reusing a strong review from one branch or service line to promote a different one the reviewer never actually used.

What enforcement actually looks like

The FTC rule authorizes civil penalties for knowing violations, with per-violation amounts tied to the statutory maximum in effect at the time, currently running well above $50,000 per violation in cases the agency chooses to pursue. For a small home service business, an FTC enforcement action is not the likely first consequence. The more immediate risk runs through competitors, consumer advocacy groups, and state attorneys general, who can act under parallel state unfair-trade-practices laws, plus the reputational cost once a filtered review feed gets noticed and screenshotted by a dissatisfied customer. The rule also gives the FTC a clearer basis for a warning letter before any penalty stage, which is the more common first contact for a small business that hasn’t drawn attention before.

A field example: a painting contractor’s review widget

A painting contractor had a review widget on its homepage, installed years earlier by a web vendor, that pulled only the five highest-rated Google reviews under the heading “What our customers really say.” At the time, the profile also carried two one-star reviews that the widget’s default rating filter quietly excluded. After a routine site audit flagged the setup, the heading changed to “A selection of our Google reviews” with a short line noting it wasn’t the complete set. The fix took a few minutes and removed the specific combination, rating-based filtering plus a completeness claim, that the rule actually targets.

The next step for your business

A quick audit of your review widget settings and a one-line disclosure next to your displayed reviews closes most of the practical risk here. Mr.Site manages websites for several hundred home service and trade businesses and checks review display settings as part of ongoing managed website service, including whether a widget is filtering by rating without anyone having asked it to. For handling an individual fake or defamatory review once it’s posted, see How to Respond to Google Reviews.