A practice website is advertising, not just information, and that single fact pulls in three separate legal frameworks at once: FTC truth-in-advertising rules, HIPAA for any identifiable patient information, and the advertising rules of the relevant state medical, dental, or professional board. Before-and-after photos and patient testimonials sit at the center of all three, and a federal enforcement action and a HIPAA settlement in 2025 both targeted exactly this content.
Why a practice website faces more than one set of rules
Unlike a contractor’s project gallery, a medical, dental, physical therapy, or medspa website advertises a health service, so the FTC’s general ban on false or misleading claims applies directly. Any photo, story, or statistic that implies a result communicates a claim, whether the practice calls it marketing or patient education. On top of that, a HIPAA-covered provider that identifies a real patient, by name, photo, or detailed treatment story, is disclosing protected health information, which needs its own authorization separate from ordinary treatment paperwork. Finally, the state board that licenses the provider, medical, dental, nursing, physical therapy, or cosmetology, usually has its own advertising rule that can be stricter than federal law.
Before-and-after photos: what the FTC actually checks
A before-and-after image communicates several claims at once: that the photo shows a real patient, that the procedure shown was actually performed, that the result is accurately represented, and that the result is reasonably achievable. The FTC’s Endorsement Guides make clear that an endorsement cannot say anything the practice could not lawfully say directly, and “individual results may vary” does not fix a misleading image on its own.
In 2025 the FTC brought an action against telemedicine company NextMed, alleging it used before-and-after photos of people who were never its customers and published fake testimonials from people who never used its weight-loss programs. The case shows both the photo and the testimonial can create liability independently, and a disclaimer would not have cured either problem.
Practical rules that follow from this:
- Use only authentic, unretouched photos of actual patients who received the exact procedure shown.
- Keep lighting, pose, and framing consistent between the before and after shot, or disclose any difference that affects the comparison.
- Do not feature an unusually successful case as if it were typical without disclosing what results are generally expected.
- Keep documentation on file, the date, the procedure, the provider, and the patient’s signed consent for each image used.
State board rules add a second layer
State rules vary by profession and by state, and they stack on top of the FTC’s standard rather than replacing it. California’s Business and Professions Code Section 651 bans advertising with false, misleading, or deceptive images, including photos that do not accurately depict results, altered photographs, and failure to identify the procedure shown in a before-and-after presentation. Texas Medical Board rules require patient consent before a physician or practice uses a patient photo in advertising at all, and treat testimonials and outcome claims as high-risk advertising that needs its own substantiation.
| Not safe | Safer |
|---|---|
| “Guaranteed results in one visit.” | “Results depend on the individual treatment plan and diagnosis.” |
| “The most effective treatment for back pain.” | “This treatment may help reduce certain symptoms.” |
| Featuring the single best outcome as the standard example | Disclosing the range of results patients generally see |
| A stock disclaimer with no other context | A disclosure of the procedure, timeframe, and typical outcome near the image |
Patient testimonials: HIPAA and the FTC rule overlap
A testimonial that names a patient, shows a photo, or describes a specific condition and treatment is protected health information under HIPAA, even when the patient volunteered it enthusiastically. A 2025 HHS Office for Civil Rights settlement with Cadia Healthcare Facilities involved exactly this: the agency alleged the provider posted a patient’s name, photo, and treatment and recovery details on its website without a valid written HIPAA marketing authorization. A standard treatment consent form or a casual verbal okay is generally not enough, the authorization needs to specifically describe the information disclosed, the purpose including the website and social media, and the patient’s right to revoke it in writing.
Separately, the FTC Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, in effect since October 21, 2024, bans publishing a testimonial from someone who never used the service, bans editing a testimonial to change its meaning, and bans presenting an atypical result as typical without disclosing what results are generally expected. The rule applies when a practice publishes testimonials on its own website, not only on third-party review platforms. Related issues around using patient images and third-party photos are covered in Photo Copyright Rules for Your Business Website, and the authenticity requirement for reviews in general is covered in Fake Reviews on Your Business Website.
It is not just the website: social media and ads count too
None of these rules stop at the practice’s own domain. The same before-and-after pair that is unsafe on a website is just as unsafe in an Instagram reel, a Facebook post, or a paid Google ad, because the FTC and most state board rules target the advertising claim itself, not the specific channel carrying it. A practice running a social campaign for an aesthetic procedure is usually better off reviewing the website, the Google Business Profile, every social account, and any paid ad creative together, rather than cleaning up the website and leaving the same content live on Instagram. A short before-and-after slider clip feels casual on social media, but it carries the exact same legal exposure as a comparison photo on a service page.
The risk level also differs by specialty, even though the underlying rules do not. A dental practice showing orthodontic aligner results is often in safer territory than a medspa or dermatology practice advertising filler or injectable results, since state boards and the FTC’s enforcement pattern have focused heavily on aesthetic and weight-loss claims. A physical therapy practice is more likely to run into the general truthfulness standard on outcome claims than the specific before-and-after photo rules, since visible before-and-after comparisons are less common for musculoskeletal treatment than for aesthetic procedures.
A pre-publish checklist
- Confirm every photo shows a real patient who actually received the procedure shown, and keep signed consent on file.
- Check whether the result shown is typical, and if it is not, disclose what results are generally expected nearby.
- Get a HIPAA marketing authorization for any identifiable patient photo, name, or treatment story, separate from standard treatment consent.
- Review the specific advertising rule of the state board that licenses the provider before publishing, since rules differ by profession and state.
- Keep testimonials limited to real experiences from people who actually used the service, and never edit one to change its meaning.
- Review social media posts and any active ad campaigns alongside the website, not as a separate, lower-priority task.
This kind of review belongs in the ongoing upkeep of a practice website, not just the launch day, since new procedures and new testimonials get added over time. Reviewing website content for compliance is part of what we cover under managed website service for practices that would rather not track every rule change themselves. None of this replaces a specific legal opinion from counsel familiar with healthcare advertising in the relevant state.