Hiring a freelance copywriter or agency to write your website copy and paying the final invoice does not automatically make you the copyright owner. Under US law, the person who wrote the text usually keeps the copyright unless the work qualifies as work made for hire or you have a signed written assignment. What you actually get without either of those is a license, and the scope of that license depends on what the contract says, or if it says nothing, on what the original engagement was reasonably for. For running your original website, that is usually enough. For switching vendors, relaunching, or reusing the copy elsewhere, it often is not.
Why the paid invoice is not the whole story
US copyright law separates two things that get blurred in everyday business: ownership of the copyright and permission to use the work. Under 17 U.S.C. Section 201, the author who actually created the work owns the copyright from the moment it is fixed, unless a specific exception applies. Freelancers and independent agencies you hire are, legally, outside contractors, not your employees. Paying their invoice settles the fee, it does not by itself shift that ownership to you.
Work made for hire: a narrower doctrine than most business owners assume
Section 101 of the Copyright Act defines a “work made for hire” in two ways:
- Work created by an employee within the scope of employment, or
- Work specially commissioned for one of nine listed categories, where both parties sign a written agreement stating it is a work made for hire.
The nine categories cover things like contributions to a collective work, translations, and compilations, not ordinary website articles or landing-page copy. A typical contractor relationship with a freelance writer or small agency usually falls outside both branches. Calling someone an “independent contractor” in an invoice, or assuming a handshake deal covers everything, does not create work-for-hire ownership on its own.
Assignment versus license: know which one you actually have
If work-for-hire does not apply, ownership only moves to you through a written assignment, required to be signed under 17 U.S.C. Section 204. Short of that, what you typically hold is a license:
- Exclusive license: only you may use the copy within the agreed scope, though the writer still owns the underlying copyright.
- Non-exclusive license: you may use the copy, but so can the writer, potentially even for other clients.
Neither type is automatically unlimited. A license granted for “use on the client’s website” can reasonably be read as covering the original site, not a fully rebuilt one on a different platform, a different business line, or a different medium like print and social media.
What a vendor switch exposes
This gap usually surfaces during a vendor switch. If you also want to understand the reverse problem, a competitor lifting your copy instead of you reusing your own, see A Competitor Copied Your Website Content: What To Do Under US Law. If a new developer simply migrates your existing copy into a new content system and the site otherwise continues the same business purpose, that typically still fits the original license. It gets riskier when the new vendor substantially rewrites the copy, builds an entirely redesigned site around it, or claims the right to reuse it in their own portfolio.
| Use case | Usually covered without a written clause? |
|---|---|
| Publishing on the original website | yes |
| Minor ongoing edits and updates | usually yes |
| Reuse on a brand new site or domain | uncertain |
| Handing the copy to an unrelated new vendor | uncertain to no |
| Reuse in social media, print, or email marketing | usually no if not specified |
| Substantial rewrite or translation | uncertain |
If your original agreement does not clearly cover the new use, the cleanest fix is a short written assignment or expanded license from the original writer before the copy moves anywhere else. That is far cheaper than a later cease-and-desist letter under Section 501.
The AI complication
If any of your website copy started as AI-generated text, ownership gets stranger, not simpler. Under current US Copyright Office guidance, purely AI-generated output is not protected by copyright at all, because the law requires human authorship and a prompt alone is not considered sufficient human control over the expressive result. Practically, that means a raw AI draft is not exclusively owned by the writer, the agency, or you. Protection only attaches to the parts a human meaningfully shaped through editing, selection, or structural rework, so a contract assigning “all rights” in AI-assisted copy can only assign what is actually copyrightable, no more.
What to put in the next contract
A short clause can close most of these gaps:
- A clear statement of whether the grant is an assignment or a license, and if a license, exclusive or non-exclusive.
- Explicit permission to reuse the copy on new sites, domains, and platforms, including after a vendor switch.
- The right to edit, shorten, and translate the copy yourself or through a new vendor.
- A statement addressing any AI-assisted drafting and who owns the human-edited result.
- Delivery of source files and draft versions at the end of the engagement.
What if an employee wrote the copy instead?
If you would rather commission the copy directly instead of sorting out licensing later, see Website Copywriting for Small Business: Cost and Options for how that process typically works. The analysis changes if the copy came from someone on your own payroll rather than an outside contractor. Under the employment branch of the work-made-for-hire doctrine in 17 U.S.C. Section 101, copy written by an employee within the scope of their job normally belongs to the employer automatically, no separate written agreement required. The practical gap between employee-written and contractor-written copy is exactly this default: an employee’s work is covered unless the parties agree otherwise, while a contractor’s work is not covered unless the parties agree it is. A departing employee does not retroactively change ownership of work they created while employed.
A real-world scenario
A plumbing company pays a small local agency 1,800 dollars in 2022 to write copy for eight service pages. The one-page agreement never mentions rights, licenses, or future use. In 2026 the company switches to a new website vendor and wants to carry the same copy over to a technically unrelated new site. Strictly read, the original engagement may not have covered that future use, since it was for the website that existed at the time, not for any future site. Few agencies would actually object to this kind of reuse, but the exposure is real, especially if the original agency has since closed and a retroactive license is no longer easy to obtain. That gap is exactly why a short rights clause in the next contract is worth more than it first appears.
Where this leaves your website
Before your next vendor switch or redesign, check whether your current contract says anything about rights at all, and if it does, how far it actually reaches. At Mr.Site, website copy is produced as part of our managed website service directly for your business, so the usage question gets settled once in the contract instead of being left open. If you already have an older site and cannot find the original paperwork, asking the original writer for a short written confirmation before you move anything is cheaper than any dispute that follows.